Today, however, we are going to discuss another type of critique that will protect you from being broken-hearted by cruel critics and help advance your career.
Point out the good and the bad and treat people with respect. If we ignore it, it will go away. I agree- we all need to give the type of critique we would want to receive.
October 31, at 3: In fact, I was ready to put what she put down! And another thing… Those folks who are belittling fellow forumites with harsh and unnecessary critiques if they can be called thatyou need to just chill and take a look at your own flaws for a moment or two, preferably before attacking someone else.
This is the WD Forum. Reshad Mikala Engel Participant I have nothing against harsh critiques. Tell the plain and simple truth. You help no one by lying, you help no one by pretending horrible writing is anything other than horrible writing.
Making people feel better does not make them write better. It usually does the reverse. Point out one good thing, and a writer will ignore the twenty-five horrible things.
October 31, at I really do think part of the problem is not understanding the differences among criticisms, feedback and critiques.
A critique is more of an analytic, editorial exercise. It is an action we have to learn and then practice to master.
I know what you mean about being talked down to as if one was stupid or childish. I had such a critique a week or so ago.
Sometimes, we just have to shrug these things off and consider the source. The very act of reaching out to communicate is a marvel.
Taking the time to a find the good in the piece — and there is, always good even in the most immature pieces, and b suggest improvements, gives the writer hope. And it IS a skill that can be learned.
Granted there are some who just come naturally to the gift, but there are others who learn it and they can achieve a level of understanding and appreciation for the ideas they want to impart. What I mean to say is, there IS no horrible writing…there are only works in various stages of progress.
Keep your cruel honesty, and send a gentle word of encouragement along with a couple specific pointers, instead.
October 31, at 6:Aug 17, · How to Critique Artwork. In this Article: Article Summary Describing the Work Analyzing the Work Interpreting the Work Judging the Work Community Q&A An art critique is a detailed analysis and evaluation of a work of art.
While no two people will experience the same reaction to a work of art, or interpret it the same way, there are a few basic guidelines you can follow to achieve a thoughtful 90%(68).
Apr 19, · Improve Your Writing: Critique Someone Else's By: Bowen Gillings. Even if you are not part of a critique group, you want people to critique your work. You want it for the most basic reason: to show that someone read what you wrote.
You want reviews from your readers. You want reactions from critics. They are not allowed to rebuttal, debate, argue or attempt in any way to refute or clarify someone’s critique of their writing.
They are, however, encouraged to take notes. The most important aspect of the critique process is that only the person’s writing is critiqued—NOT the person and NOT their story.
Although the design profession doesn't involve loads of writing, it does involve multiple forms of writing; In a magazine, on an internet site, critiquing someone else's work, writing a book, or writing up a contract.
Aug 20, · Be well-read, preferably in the genre of the writing. Your critique will be more effective if you have a background in the genre or area of the writing, such as being an avid reader of science fiction if asked to critique someone's science fiction manuscript%(32). Oct 15, · What do you do when you find a friend asking you to critique their story?
What are some best practices to help both you and them? What should you say when you ask someone .